Who is Red John?

Theories of James JC aka AA (1)

Its no coincidence Patrick started helping the CBI on the Redjohn case 10 years ago. Redjohn has always had an eye out for Patrick. Redjohn knew Patrick from their days in the carnival. What makes me so sure?

Tangie Ambrose, same age as Jane + in the carnival, comes for the episode with the flashbacks of Redjohn.

- Bertram calls Patrick the 'Boy Wonder' (in season 3 I think)

We know that's what Patrick's father called him + its what their show was called. Who else knew Patrick's father and called him a con man? Bret Stiles and Sean Barlow. Sean Barlow even suggests RJ is psychic, but we know he's not.

Who else is supposedly "psychic"? Kristina Frye. The "Roll tide" trick could be done if say someone like Haffner, a former-football player like O'Loughlin, who knows Redjohn, (maybe won Heisman cup), knew the waiter from a while ago. So she's on RJ's "team." Ellis Mars? He gives Patrick a calling card with a tiger... Tiger, tiger?  

- McCallister when he first meets Patrick mocks him, saying "You psychic or something?"
- Partridge asks him "Hoovering up the psychic ectoplasm there?"

Anyway, Rosalynd Harker is the right age to be the dying girl Patrick and his father conned. But how could Rosalynd ever be known by name to Redjohn? We know Patrick leaves his father. Does Alex Jane find another apprentice and mention to him, how his son Patrick left, and his last con which he nearly ruined with the dying girl?

How does Bret Stiles know Alex Jane? Did Bret have a son who worked on the Visualise farm, the one who murdered 2 people? Did Bret Stiles' son run away to the carnival after Patrick had already left his father? Did he becomes Alex Jane's new apprentice? We know Alex Jane resented Patrick for what he did. Haffner is an creative surveillance expert, a good tool for Redjohn. Did he help track down Rosalynd Harker? Is that how Harker really met Roy?

We know one of the Kirkland's said "We moved for Dad's work. We moved for Mom's work" to Lisbon. Were they in the carnival maybe? Is that where Redjohn was? Is that why Bob Kirkland thought Patrick Jane was Redjohn? I mean how else would Michael randomly meet Redjohn?

Why did Jay Roth go to meet Sophie Miller in person? He really did want to meet someone close to Patrick. 


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on